3 player deal. Is this worth it?

[Fiddler]

10 team PPR league

Trade off ADP, S. Greene, and D. Bowe

Get in return:
Michael Turner, Andre Johnson, Ryan Grant


QB: Romo/ McNabb
RB: A. Peterson/ S. Greene
WR: C. Johnson/ L. Fitzgerald/ D. Bowe
TE: v. Davis
Flex: S. Moss/ J. Best
K: G. Hartley
Def: Jets

[POJO_Risin]

No....

You already have stud receivers...so you don't need Andre...

Michael Turner has questions galore about health...and I think the Greene/Grant is a wash...

In the end, even in a PPR, I don't think it makes you better...and wash trades make no sense to me.

I'd stand pat...

Help if you can...

viewtopic.php?t=471984

[BalancedMan]

I usually like to get the best player back in the trade and AP is clearly the guy. But you would get the #1 receiver, a stud RB in Turner and not bad in Grant. That's a really, really fair trade in my opinion. I guess it depends on league rules for scoring. Is there a reason he wants AP so bad? Maybe you can swap Greene for Best. I think you'd have to do that trade if he took it.

He gets the best player (AP) but you get #2 and #3 would both be first round picks in Johnson and Turner. You're getting more balanced value, which helps to mitigate against risk of injury...hmm...tempting.

[kswiss]

That's definitely a tough choice. I see both sides of it. ADP is obviously the best player in that trade, and normally you would want to be keeping the best player. I don't think you can go wrong by not taking the trade. ADP could carry your team. But if I also see Grant as a better option than Greene. I don't know what to think about Greene this year. He's set up to get a big workload in a run first offense. However, could he get injured again, or how many touches will LT get? If you're not confident with Greene, then do the deal. Turner will still get you home run type games, and AJ is a HUGE upgrade over Bowe.

[MWRtodayy]

Honestly I'd do it in a heartbeat. Yeah your downgrading
A little from ap to MT. but your upgrading huge from bowe to Aj. A fourth/fifth round wr
To a 1st. And Ryan grant is the only rb in GB so he'll get all the carries while Greene shares with LT who should take away 100-150 carries, ESP goal lines

[c0megets0me]

Looks like a good trade but I think your team is better the way it is now. But I would consider trading Greene.