Rate it Up...Be Critical WHIR

[marley972]

Just give me your honest opinion. 2 leagues, we will call them (14team-A, 12team-B)

A 14 Team, PPR, Start- QB, WR, WR, RB, RB, WR/RB, TE, K, 3 indvidual def players
I just want feedback on the offense
QB- Rothlesberger, M. Cassel, D. Anderson
RB- Ray Rice, C. Benson, R. Bush, Bernard Scott, Rashard Jennings
WR- M. Colston, Ochocinco, Houshmanzada, James Jones, Ted Ginn
TE-V. Shianco

B 12 Team, Standard, Start-QB, WR, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, K, DEF
QB- A Rodgers
WR- R. Moss, M. Colston, P. Garcon, Houshmanzada, Jacoby Jones, Devone Bess
RB- R. Mendenhall, Ronnie Brown, Jahvid Best, J. Addai
TE- Zach Miller
DEF- Green Bay

Leave Link and I will respond

[RASportsnut]

Team A: weak at QB, but Anderson is a sleeper, so hopefully he'll cover for you until Ben comes back. Love Rice (I have him also), and you've got two quality receivers and an above average TE.

Team B: One of the real elite QBs. I believe Best will be very good this year to make your RBs very strong. Moss is elite, Colston can be, and Jones looks to have all the skills to become one. Good job in this draft.


Rate mine? viewtopic.php?t=472247

[Hothouse1966]

14-team ppr league:
You'll get by with the QBs you have, I'm more concerned about your WRs in a ppr format; I don't like Housh or Ginn to get many recs at all, meaning you're relying on Colston and Ochocinco to carry you. RB depth is a little shallow but Bush does catch the ball a lot so helps with the ppr format; Scott and Jennings are throw-aways unless Benson or MJD get hurt.

12-team standard league:
I really like your WRs - Moss, Colston, Garcon and Jacoby should be enough to carry the burden, while Bess has upside with Marshall drawing the opposing def top corner. As I said earlier, Housh is probably washed up, but with your depth you can afford to wait him out. Similarly, you have excellent depth at RB and I agree that Best will be the gem that makes your team a very good one. You may be able to pakage Addai or Brown with Garcon or Jacoby to upgrade your WR if you want to land a top stud WR. Between Mendenhall and Best, I think you'll be set at RB assuming you have at least one of Brown and Addai as backup. If you could swing a deal for Fitz/White/Calvin/Austin you'd be the team to beat in your league.