Desean for Smith (Car) + sims-walker?

[amir7]

ive been offered Steve Smith from the panthers and Sims-walker for Desean jackson. I like Jackson, but im unsure of his production this year with kolb at the helm. should i go ahead with the deal, im really thin at WR.

10 team league, standard format, no PPR
QB: Schaub, Ryan
RB: Turner, Mendenhall, Ronnie B, M. Bush, Hightower
WR: D-jax, knox, wallace, dez
TE: Zach Miller, Carlson

thanks

[ShaqAttaq13]

Honestly, I'm a bit of a "hater" on Desean.. but I would almost trade him straight up for Smith.. so def. do this.

[RBManiac]

WR: D-jax, knox, wallace, dez

_____

It really depends on how many recievers you can start.

if you can only start 3 recievers, then no way, its not worth it.

You would already Be starting D-Jax, Knox, and wallace, losing DJax, and then having to decide if you would rather start Smith, Walker or both, and having to bench Wallace will be more of a headache than advantage. more cons...

Smith is older, and coming back from an injury.
Walker is inconsistant at times, and also has injury concerns.

Its not PPR, DJax is a yardage monster. He wont have the catches, but he will have 2 of them for 100yards and a TD which makes him kinda a stud in non ppr, in fact all of your starting players are essentially yardage monsters.

Good vibes i get from your starting lineup. If you dump Jax for those two, then its leaning towards bad vibes.



Now, if you can start 4 WRs, then it might be something to really consider, the production you recieve from walker/smith should be better than Dez/DJax

Stick with what you have


oh and

Honestly, I'm a bit of a "hater" on Desean.. but I would almost trade him straight up for Smith.. so def. do this.

not so fast

[Chalfdiggity]

thats a tough trade to pass up. Your not that thin at wr and can start wallace who should be solid #2wr Even with Kolb at the helm Desean is a monster and since its not a ppr league his value is really high.. I dont think you need to do it but you are getting decent value in this trade for D. Jackson. But all in all, i wouldnt do the deal. You will be awesome with wallace and d jackson starting for you. IF you start 3wr then i would lean toward yes bc i dont believe knox is that good.

Please help with mine...
viewtopic.php?t=472407

[RBManiac]

Even with Kolb at the helm Desean is a monster and since its not a ppr league his value is really high

exactly as other repeat the same thing im telling you, that should be reassurance.

It might be Kolb behind center, but hes a better QB(on paper at least) than Gerrard, and hes in a much better situation with all the surrounding talent. Kolb is also ALOT better than Matt Moore.


too much downside in this trade..if you needed another reciever badly, then you probly have no choice, but since you dont...you dont need to do the trade, it doesnt really help you much

[curtk]

I have to agree that you don't need the depth to give up Desean, unless you start four WRs, as mentioned above. Barring that, I wouldn't do it.

Help with mine?
viewtopic.php?t=472412

[amir7]

thanks for the help guys.

i can play up to 3 recievers, but ill probably only use 2 most of the time. A backfield of Turner,Brown and Mendenhall will be hard to pass up week in week out. I'll probably keep jackson