Addai for Jennings? WHIR

[Cameron10483]

I give:

Addai, S Moss (wash)

I get:

Jennings, Meacham

At first glance I like this, but Addai is a TD machine on a high octane offense. Colts are leary about Donald Brown (whom I own) because he can't pass block and that's a big no no when Manning is your QB. I see another 10 TD's easy for Addai. I also like S Moss this year w/ McNabb, and though he isn't a starter he could see some time for byes and injuries and we start 3 flex, so you never know. Anyway, what do you all think? The rest of my team is in my sig. Thanks and WHIR.

[Prestige Worldwide]

thanks for the help on mine

I've never been a huge fan of Jennings or Addai, so this one can go either way for me. would be useful to see the rest of your rbs and wrs and how many you start so we can see your depth.

[Cameron10483]

Hey, it's in my signature below my post. We start QB, RB, RB, WR, WR, W/R/T x 3, TE, K, DEF

Addai is currently my #2 flex as I have CJ, Grant, Arian Foster, Addai, Felix Jones at RB and they all start as RB or Flex, but I'd just slide Jennings in Addai's slot....I'm just worried that Addai will get injured as he's already had a concussion in pre-season, but when he is healthy he scores top 10 RB #'s every year as he's a TD machine. I think he has like 36 TD's in his last 40 games or something like that.

[Prestige Worldwide]

sorry it didnt show up when i was replying.

looking at that i would keep addai myself. i always favor starting a rb in a flex over a wr. and you have marshall and austin. you also have brown, so if addai gets hurt you have the Indy rb position locked up, and vice versa.

[TruNinerFan]

This is a tough one. I am not a big fan of Addai, but like you said he is a starting Rb in a high octane offense. But, I think jennings is really going to explode this year. You have decent depth at both positions, so you don't really have to make a deal. It comes down to personal prefereance, who do you think is going to have a bigger year. I personally think jennings, but you could really flip a coin on this one. I don't think this trade will make or break your team either way.

[Cameron10483]

Thanks Niner, I think I'm gonna take it. I think Addai is just too injury prone and I have Brown. I also have a greater trade value piece in Jennings than I do in Addai, I believe.

[letsgobirds]

I can basically second what 49er said. Your depth at both positions is fine so it comes down to who you like more. I'm not the biggest Addai fan, but he will get his TD's (guessing this isn't PPR where he can be even more valuable). IF i had to say one way or another I would probably decline this and start a 3rd RB at flex, but I don't think this will make or break your entire season either way.

thanks for mine