Please help, Which is a more dominant roster?

[FF_God]

Which roster should I have for dominance and stability? Thanks! It's a 12 team yahoo standard league, non PPR : 1 QB: 2 RBs: 2 WRs: 1 TE: 1 TE/WR flex: 1 Def: 1 kicker

Roster 1:
My current lineup
QB: Romo, Stafford, Anderson
RB: Turner, Bradshaw, Huggins
WR: Andre Johnson, Wallace, Aromashadu, Sidney Rice
TE: Witten, Finley
Def: Arizona, oakland
K: gostgowski

OR with a trade, this can be my roster.

Roster 2:
My current lineup
QB: Romo, Stafford, Anderson
RB: McCoy, Bradshaw, Huggins
WR: Andre Johnson, Fitzgerald, Wallace, Aromashadu, Sidney Rice
TE: Finley
Def: Arizona, oakland
K: gostgowski