Giving up too much? Possibluh. WHIR!!

[scottster92]

12 Team H2H..Every TD worth 10 points... and L.T. is a backup and im looking to trade for Maurice Jones Drew, since Jackson gets tons of yards but no TD, which holds the most weight in our league. Do I even need to trade or just stay put... someone offered me MJD AND Dexter McCluster for my Colston and Jackson. Whatcha think? Thanks

QB Drew Brees
WR Marques Colston
WR Mike Sims-Walker
WR Jeremy Maclin
RB Steven Jackson
RB LaDainian Tomlinson
TE Dallas Clark
Q/W/R/T Eli Manning
BN Santonio Holmes
BN Kevin Smith
BN Sam Bradford

K David Akers

LB DeMarcus Ware
DT Darnell Dockett
DE Mario Williams
DE Justin Smith
CB Asante Samuel
CB Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie
S Adrian Wilson
BN London Fletcher
BN Eric Berry
BN Darrelle Revis

[Indibuck]

He's asking a little too much IMHO. I'd much rather have McCluster as a bench or flex player than a starter.

[DemonDeacon]

ya thats too much... you need at the very least a GOOD week to week option instead of McCluster... who is being valued way to high

[runningchoc]

I dunno,the more I think about this, the more I think it could be worth it. Say Colston and Jackson each get 8td's this year. If MJD goes for 12-14 then all you need is 4 from the replacement WR, and when Holmes is back, you've got a much bolstered starting lineup. It's a big risk though, because I am a little high on SJax with Bradford around to open up the redzone plays.

[scottster92]

Since MJD didnt do much fantasy wise today, I figure I can take advantage.. he also doesnt have a qb. literally has Alex Smith. So I picked up M. Vick, and he said he wanted him. I took Colston out of it.. and now he just said Vick and Jackson haha. Im assuming I should do it?

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

Ya I would do it

[clarkevii]

I would NOT do this. McCluster is overvalued / MJD is too risky... I would hold onto Jackson. MJD not MUCH better.