McNabb and ? for Cutler.....WHIR

[Hoosierdad]

Another team has bad WRs. He starts Harvin, Meachem and Breaston. He has 3 good QBs (Schaub, Cutler, Flacco). He just offered me Cutler for McNabb and Sims-Walker. I don't think there's enough difference between Cutler and McNabb for that, so wanted some opions on who I should counter with. Here are my possible choices. I don't think he'll go for any of them, but figured it's worth a try:

Williams (TB), Williams (SEA), Gaffney, Evans

Any of those to go along with McNabb?

Or, I could offer McNabb and Knox for Flacco. Then he would have the Cutler/Knox combo and I think Flacco might be better this year anyway.

Leave a link.

[two_step08]

hmmm thats a tough one.. is it a 2 QB league? otherwise, i cant see why he has 3 good QBs... if its not, hes probably desperate to give up a QB, so i would probably try for flacco, but like you said, i dont know if theres enough difference between mcnabb and whoever to throw in sims-walker in addition.. unless your really high on cutler or flacco i wouldnt do it, unless hed take like mike williams (sea) and mcnabb for one of them. its just my opinion, but it seems like whatever way you slice it hes getting the better end of the stick

[Hoosierdad]

Yep, 2 QB league. He rolled the dice and took 3 good QBs but he's been asking for way too much for one of them. Now he's stuck.