Stewart, Nicks or Aromashodu

[Double A]

I need flex help...ppr league.

Stewart @ NYG (tougher matchup, doesn't catch many balls, but when he finds the endzone, he can be a monster)

Nicks vs. Car (decent secondary in Carolina)

Aramoshodu vs Det (great matchup, but what will his role be in Martz offense? He had some huge games last year and has big upside).

I can only start one of them by the way...

[Rabbit]

Tough call. I would probably go with J Stewart.

[Archeon]

Thanks for helping on mine.


I think I would go with Stewart as the Person Above me said.

[Red Winger]

I think Stewart gets the nod - barely - over Nicks. The PPR doesn't help much with Nicks as he is the deep threat, so if he catches 3 for 70 and a TD (likely) you get 16. Stewart will most certainly ge t 70 rush, 25 rec (2-3 catches) and at least one TD. You get 17. But Stewart also has the potential to put up 120/40/2TDs. Nicks doesn't.

Thanks for the help on mine

[SameSongNDance]

I think Stewart gets the nod - barely - over Nicks. The PPR doesn't help much with Nicks as he is the deep threat, so if he catches 3 for 70 and a TD (likely) you get 16. Stewart will most certainly ge t 70 rush, 25 rec (2-3 catches) and at least one TD. You get 17. But Stewart also has the potential to put up 120/40/2TDs. Nicks doesn't.

Thanks for the help on mine

Hehe you're making it sound like Stewart isn't apart of a two-headed monster. I'd give the nod to Stewart due to consistency but IMO Nicks is a higher risk/reward candidate. Depends on which role you need filled.

[Red Winger]

I think Stewart gets the nod - barely - over Nicks. The PPR doesn't help much with Nicks as he is the deep threat, so if he catches 3 for 70 and a TD (likely) you get 16. Stewart will most certainly ge t 70 rush, 25 rec (2-3 catches) and at least one TD. You get 17. But Stewart also has the potential to put up 120/40/2TDs. Nicks doesn't.

Thanks for the help on mine

Hehe you're making it sound like Stewart isn't apart of a two-headed monster. I'd give the nod to Stewart due to consistency but IMO Nicks is a higher risk/reward candidate. Depends on which role you need filled.

Oh no, I've had DWill on my team 3 years running, I know what CAR's running game does inside and out. I think Stewart and Nicks have about the same floor, but Stewart has higher upside IMO.

[KenDawg19]

I'm with the majority. Stewart has the higher ceiling over the others.

Thanks for mine.

[SameSongNDance]

I think Stewart gets the nod - barely - over Nicks. The PPR doesn't help much with Nicks as he is the deep threat, so if he catches 3 for 70 and a TD (likely) you get 16. Stewart will most certainly ge t 70 rush, 25 rec (2-3 catches) and at least one TD. You get 17. But Stewart also has the potential to put up 120/40/2TDs. Nicks doesn't.

Thanks for the help on mine

Hehe you're making it sound like Stewart isn't apart of a two-headed monster. I'd give the nod to Stewart due to consistency but IMO Nicks is a higher risk/reward candidate. Depends on which role you need filled.

Oh no, I've had DWill on my team 3 years running, I know what CAR's running game does inside and out. I think Stewart and Nicks have about the same floor, but Stewart has higher upside IMO.

I'm riding the Nicks hype train this year. I think that trick where he pulled the queen of hearts out of the air got to me. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YIZzfmmhzEg <---. I tend to think Nicks has higher upside but we shall see. I still say go with JStew here though . I know, not many teams can supply a two-headed monster with enough reps but CAR is definitely one of them. It's just, 120/40/2 TD's is more of something he did when DWill was sidelined with an injury. I just don't see him putting up those numbers when sharing reps is all.

[iuprell67]

Go with Stewart

[GiantFanatic]

I would have said Stewart because I think you want a player who's going to get more attempts. However, Stewarts averages are actually lower than one would think, so while the matchup is better than Nicks Nicks probably has the better opportunity.

In case you're interested, I used this tool:
http://www.bloombergsports.com/fanofferings/football/

It's pretty close, but I'd probably play Stewart anyway. I don't like the matchup numbers the Bloomberg Sports Decision Maker tool showed me.

Best,
GF