Which WR? Nicks, Maclin, or Evans? WHIR!

[devastor]

In a 14 team league and I have the following matchups to pick 1 WR.

H. Nicks vs CAR
J. Maclin vs GB
L. Evans vs. MIA

Believe it or not I am pushing toward Evans but will they even throw the ball?

Help me out and leave a link.

[TheBlackChip]

Certainly not Evans. While Nicks-Maclin is a virtual toss up this week, I'd go with Nicks, you don't want to read too much into matchups, and Nicks seems to be the more talented of the two, and has a more established QB.

[devastor]

thanks. anyone else?

[Chuong9]

This decision is definitely between H. Nicks and J. Maclin. I would give the slight edge to H. Nicks because J. Maclin has an extremely unfavorable match up and I don't think very highly of K. Kolb. I believe H. Nicks has a greater potential for targets, and thus production.

viewtopic.php?t=472452

[Thor]

I'm going to look at this decision this way.

Kolb is going to have a decent year. He will throw alot of picks but he will pile up yards and TDs along the way.

GBs secondary is banged up, I think GB's offense wins the game for them and Philly will be throwing from behind most of the game. Woodson will be covering DJax, so that will leave Maclin against the rest of the second string secondary.

I like Maclin this week

I like Nicks over the long haul.

viewtopic.php?t=473081

[sask]

I would say its a toss up but Philly will be throwing more this week so Maclin is probably your right choice.

viewtopic.php?t=473080

[devastor]

The problem is Maclin & Nicks are deep threat, #3 WR. How is that better than Evans?