Should I do this trade? WHIR

[amarlls]

I got offered Mike Sims-walker and Mason Crosby for my Jamaal Charles?? Should I do this? Im pretty stacked at RB as it stands but dont know if walker is enough or would even do anything this year. I do need crosby as solid K but am i giving upo too much

Peyton Manning, Ind QB
RB Ray Rice, Bal RB
RB Jahvid Best, Det RB
RB/WR Arian Foster, Hou RB
WR Brandon Marshall, Mia WR P
WR Jabar Gaffney, Den WR
TE Visanthe Shiancoe, Min TE
D/ST Vikings D/ST, Min D/ST
K Lawrence Tynes, NYG K

Bench Pierre Thomas, NO RB
Bench Jamaal Charles, KC RB
Bench Hines Ward, Pit WR
Bench Hakeem Nicks, NYG WR
Bench Malcom Floyd, SD WR

[harold_bush]

F*ck no! That's an awful trade in my opinion. Sims-WAlker, like most of hte Jax offense outside of MJD is goign to be veyr inconsistent. They don't pass enough to their wideouts. You are arguably giving up a second round RB for a 5th, 6th, 7th round WR. Kickers are kickers, so I don't care about Crosby at all. Prolific offense yes, but htat doesn't mean a great fantasy kicker b/c the offense can sscore too many TDs leading to extra point chances instead of FGs.

Shoot MUCH higher if you are giving up Charles. For the record I'm not even a big Charles guy either.

viewtopic.php?t=473341

[amarlls]

Ya i tryed for a calvin johnson or roddy white from him and he shut it down. He doesnt really have anyone else. jsut hard to hold that much RB and having to sit these studs every week