Johnson or Nicks for WK 2?

[Bigpop]

Hey all. I lost this week in a close game, simply because I started Calvin Johnson and sat Hakeem Nicks. My other WR is Steve Smith (Car.). With Smith playing TB, I expect he will have another productive day. So my dilemma is now Johnson, who has lost his QB or Nicks who may very well be Manning's new favorite number 1 receiver who has a break out year.

With Stafford out, it looks like Hill is gonna just throw the ball to Calvin, but I am concerned about him being doubled and thus much less effective. Which means my biggest (or most obvious) replacement is Nicks. I'm struggling with not making a silly move because of one bad week but also trying to make sensible moves to improve my team and sometimes the "big name" guys need to sit.

Opinions/ideas welcome. Thanks ahead of time!

[Jai]

Tough one...as a Giants fan I believe that Smith and Nicks are gonna alternate big games. As an owner of Calvin Johnson I can't see myself benching him this early. I know that doesn't help you at all just my .02 worth. I'm kinda in the same boat with Rice in that it's tough to bench your "big names" but sometimes it does need to be done.

viewtopic.php?f=19&t=473463#p3227418