Trade! Ryan Mathews for Schaub? WHIR

[TuffDongKong]

Mathews and Cutler for Schaub and Bush? He has Marion Barber, but I like Bush more.

QB- Jay Cutler, Matt Ryan
WR- Calvin Johnson, Wes Welker, Dwayne Bowe, Mike Williams, Julian Edelman
RB- Chris Johnson, Ryan Mathews, Adrian Foster, Ahmad Bradshaw, LenDale White
TE- Zach Miller
K- Garrett Hartley
DEF- Minnesota

YAHOO (12TEAMS)

QB, WR, WR, WR, RB, RB, TE, K, DEF

Passing Yards (50 yards per point; 5 points at 300 yards)
Passing Touchdowns (6)
Interceptions (-2)
Rushing Attempts (.10)
Rushing Yards (20 yards per point; 5 points at 100 yards)
Rushing Touchdowns (6)
Receptions (.25)
Reception Yards (20 yards per point; 5 points at 100 yards)
Reception Touchdowns (6)
Return Touchdowns (6)
2-Point Conversions (2)
Fumbles Lost (-2)

[Kibbles and Vick]

I'm no fantasy expert but I figured I'll at least throw out my input.

Thats a pretty tough trade right there.

Schaub will have a better fantasy season than cutler for sure. Especially with the -2 per interceptions. What did he throw 26 or something like that last season. But Mathews will have a better fantasy season than Bush for sure. Pierre Thomas is getting the majority of the carries in new orleans right now. Who is a pass heavy offense as is. And they seem to have established a decent power running game with Thomas as showcased in the second half of the saints/vikings game. It is only week one though.

I guess you just have to weigh your gains losses. BTW whats your receiving yards points look like. Bush seems to get a lot of check down throws, so you will have to factor in receiving with rushing.

[TuffDongKong]

We get .5 per Reception and 1 for 20 yards. I should have clarified the offer is Michael Bush, not Reggie. Michael Bush is hurt, but should be back soon. Although McFadden did well against Tenn.

[Kibbles and Vick]

ahh sorry I didn't see you had reception yards posted already. My bad.


I'de go for the trade and take Schaub Bush. Your QB's are looking pretty weak and you have what seems to me right now the best 2 RB's already in Chris Johnson/ Arian Foster. You need a decent starting QB

[Kibbles and Vick]

ahh okay. Yeah Mcfadden did do well last week. That does present a risk. There playing the ram's next week and there 29th in run defense. I read Bush will have limited if any carries. I'm sure Mcfadden won't steal the starting position although I'm sure he will eat into his carries.


Dang thats a tough one haha

[TuffDongKong]

Should I try to trade for a top WR like AJ, Moss, or Austin instead?

[TuffDongKong]

Help?

[calicocal]

Personally I do this trade. Schaub has the potential to be a top 3 QB and I think Cutler will be throwing close to 30 ints this year plus fumbling more than once or twice. Looking at your RB's you have a solid group. Starting only 2 RB's You wont be sitting CJ2k and I cant see you playing Mathews over Foster. I think once Bush is healthy he gets the job. If there is one thing that McFadden has proven is that he can't be the guy.

Take a look at mine viewtopic.php?f=18&t=473611&p=3228001#p3228001

[TuffDongKong]

Please more help

[the prize fighter]

personally i like mike martz syystem for cutler and forte. i expect both to have a good fantasy year under mike martz. I think you are selling ryan mathews WAY to low for an injured bush who might have had his job stolen by mcfadden. Lets be hoest Tenn has a SOLID D and mcfadden made them look stupid. Tom cable has no idea what to do at RB he's never consistant with showing who's the # 1 at running back. so i think you should keep your players, even tho schaub will be a little better than cutler i think your getting ripped off on your RB return thats crazy. ryan mathews was your 2 round possibly even first round pick. don't let him go becuz he under performed on his first NFL start. Good Luck.