Mcnabb or Vick?????

[Alkaholik]

10 Team League

1 Point per 10 yards rushing
1 Point per 50 yards passing
6 Points per Rush or Pass TD

Do i start Mcnabb or do i drop Mcnabb and pickup Vick for the week since rushing yards are worth so much???


Donovan Mcnabb, WAS - QB vs HOU

or

Mike Vick, PHI - QB @ DET

Mcnabb looked bad vs Dallas and the offense didnt get much but they are playing houston, vick looked good, but GB didnt have a gameplan for a rushing QB, he plays Detroit this week and gets a lot of points for Rushing...who do i go with???/

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

Vick

[jp05ser]

this might seem silly but wait and see if Vick is named the started I live in Philly and right now they arent ruling outy Kolb and wont till at least friday or saturday. Now my feeling is they are going to rule him out. but just making sure ur aware of it. If Vick starts I go with him. Mcnabb looked horrible and has no one to throw to. on top of that he doesnt have much of a running game to keep any D honest. Although the Lions looked better (based off 1 week) they have too much to gameplan for with Vicks running ability and all the options he has to throw to. hope this helps... please help with mine.... viewtopic.php?f=19&t=473685

[bagofmilk]

First of all, HOU played AWESOME vs. the Colts. And they held Peyton the first half, then Peyton went crazy the 2nd half. Look to see McNabb getting rushed often.

You can make a conservative guess at to what each might do:

Vick: 200 passing yards, 80 rushing yds. 2 TDs = 24 pts
McNabb: 300 passing yards, 20 rushing yds. 2 TDs. = 20pts

Of course these are wild guesses, and largely speculative.

[Alkaholik]

thanks guys, i'm thinking i will drop mcnabb and roll with vick if vick is the starter.

for those who provided well thought out responses, i submitted very helpful feedback for your posts.

very much appreciated.