P Thomas 4 Wes Welker would you?

[PITTBOSS]

rest of my line up, PPR, 1RB 2WR, 1 RB/WR.

P Manning
P Thomas C Benson
M Colston J Jones
B Scaife
L Tynes
Patriots

B Roethlisberger (R)
F Taylor (R) J Forsett (R) L Maroney (R)
D Bess (R) M Wallace (R)
A Fasano (R)
Jaguars (R)

[LMack]

Nope I don't like your backs enough here to move Thomas.

[elwood5582]

I would do it. Welker is a PPR rape!

[snixx79]

Interesting. Welker is a PPR monster, but moving PT would leave you with Just Benson....Forsett on the bench could be a low bye week fill in i suppose, but if anything happens to Cedric you would be FINISHED. If you could drop Maroney and grab Bernard Scott as insurance i would...then, and ONLY then would i even consider this....I would also then start Welker, Wallace, Colston and Benson as opposed to any of your other RB's or Jones (James or Jacoby...?)



Mine?

viewtopic.php?t=473838

[aznf007]

So this is a tough debacle you have here. They are both very studly players and in a ppr league they will both do well. However, I believe that Pierre Thomas is a better value than Wes Welker is. He is a great rb and a decent receiver on NO high powered offense. If you were to trade away Thomas, you would be left to start Benson and Forsett, and they are better as your number 2 and 3 backs. If you want Wes, you can try and trade him Benson + somebody else although I doubt that he would accept. I say keep Thomas because he has higher overall value.

[MadDog36]

Post FA RB and WR please.
Don't do the deal and Welker is a beast in PPR, if you had one more quality back I'd say yes.

I hope that's the Wallace in SEA

[snixx79]

Post FA RB and WR please.
Don't do the deal and Welker is a beast in PPR, if you had one more quality back I'd say yes.

I hope that's the Wallace in SEA

Im assuming its Mike Wallace, WR, Pittsburgh (who is a stud to be by the way). Oh, and Seneca Wallace, who i believe you are talking about, has been in Cleveland for some time now.

[MadDog36]

So many Williams and Wallace out there, just call me Braveheart.