HELP! SHAUBB OR ELI? who to start?

[951ffstud]

I dont wanta bench shaubb but eli played so well last week...what to do?

[Andy1234]

Historically Indy doesn't stop the run, but they have been good against the pass. Scaub was hurt buy this last week and I expect him to be fine this week. Eli is against Indy this week. I'd feel good starting Schaub this week.

Help with mine: Best or McFadden?

[951ffstud]

And should i drop Maclin for Naanee or Clayton?

[Andy1234]

And should i drop Maclin for Naanee or Clayton?

I lke Clayton better than Nenee. If you have no one else to drop, I would drop Maclin for Clayton. I like Maclin, but I like Calyton better.

[951ffstud]

Goodpoint, thanks man.

[Navyseal]

Hold on folks... Schaub for sure, and I'm an Eli owner and Skins honk... but --- drop Maclin for Clayton? No chance, not even with Vick under center in Philly, Maclin DID score last week, may I remind you, and Clayton has NEVER been consistent imo... Maclin gets carries too, lest we forget...
GL!



*Big $$$ 12 tm, H2H Hyper-performance/Milestone keeper league:
QB-RB-RB-WR-WR-WR-TE-K-D/ST + several other options
*Eli, McNabb
*AP,*JStew, T.Jones, MBush, Slaton
*Austin,*R.White,*Royal, Manningham, M.Thomas, Edelman
*O.Daniels
*Kaeding
*NE D/ST, NYG D/ST
(1-0)

[951ffstud]

Do you think Maclin is a risky start? I need someone i can start, Clayton had 16 targets...i would feel more better starting him.

[TheBull]

Schaub easily and dont drop Maclin for Clayton but this week i would start Clayton....If Vick is QB long-term that will hurt all Philly's WR's numbers.

[951ffstud]

Maclin just doesnt seem tempting, with Desean Jackson there and Vick running a lot. Clayton on the other hand might be a little more consisten and will eventually be #1.

[Navyseal]

One last nugget regarding Maclin/Clayton --- Maclin's hands seem "surer" than Clayton's ever have been (esp. in the endzone last year), although Clayton has come up with the highlight reel "circus catch" from time to time in the past w/ BALT, but his "key drops" (think New England last season) stand out more than any of his scant "key grabs"... Vick will extend plays and in turn, DRIVES, and move the chains w/ the aid of his feet, while Bradford seems to be more at the mercy of how well his O-Line pass-blocks... pocket passer or not, Vick is a VET, and Sam is still a ROOK...

OK, carry on then... lol