Saw this on the rotoworld forums and thought it would be interesting to see how much people's perceptions of players change once you get to see them a week in. I thought it was pretty interesting to see Charles on most of the top 5 lists for people, would be pretty good since I have him heh.
1. Adrian Peterson 2. Chris Johnson 3. SJax 4. Arian Foster 5. MJD
I think Charles makes it into the top 5 if he is given the opportunity but most likely will be a borderline top 10 back.
sadlyajetsfan wrote:Saw this on the rotoworld forums and thought it would be interesting to see how much people's perceptions of players change once you get to see them a week in. I thought it was pretty interesting to see Charles on most of the top 5 lists for people, would be pretty good since I have him heh.
1. Adrian Peterson 2. Chris Johnson 3. SJax 4. Arian Foster 5. MJD
I think Charles makes it into the top 5 if he is given the opportunity but most likely will be a borderline top 10 back.
This is utterly absurd. Any list that has SJax and Foster above MJD needs to be disregarded. Foster has 488 CAREER rushing yards and SJax has scored double-digit TD's in a season exactly ONCE. MJD has scored at least 14 TD's in 3 of the past 4 seasons.
I'm gonna laugh when Foster has like 3 or 4 weeks in a row of 50 or less rushing yards.
He's a good back but what happened last week is definitely not something to expect every week. Maybe he'll be top 10 or top 15, I'd be shocked if he finishes in the top 5 ahead of guys like MJD.
abrunn11 wrote: This is utterly absurd. Any list that has SJax and Foster above MJD needs to be disregarded. Foster has 488 CAREER rushing yards and SJax has scored double-digit TD's in a season exactly ONCE. MJD has scored at least 14 TD's in 3 of the past 4 seasons.
Then disregard it, don't know what to tell you. Didn't see you put anything out there. I agree with the other person, I can easily see MJD going down and that's why I put him at the tail end of top 5. Foster is in an offense that he can thrive in and week one he did well, can't just put that all on a bad defense. SJax has the potential to be a top 5 back. Don't see what is so absurd about that list. Besides what's the fun in putting out a 1. Chris Johnson 2. Adrian Peterson 3. Ray Rice 4. MJD 5. Frank Gore list.
abrunn11 wrote: This is utterly absurd. Any list that has SJax and Foster above MJD needs to be disregarded. Foster has 488 CAREER rushing yards and SJax has scored double-digit TD's in a season exactly ONCE. MJD has scored at least 14 TD's in 3 of the past 4 seasons.
Then disregard it, don't know what to tell you. Didn't see you put anything out there. I agree with the other person, I can easily see MJD going down and that's why I put him at the tail end of top 5. Foster is in an offense that he can thrive in and week one he did well, can't just put that all on a bad defense. SJax has the potential to be a top 5 back. Don't see what is so absurd about that list. Besides what's the fun in putting out a 1. Chris Johnson 2. Adrian Peterson 3. Ray Rice 4. MJD 5. Frank Gore list.
Dude, you did not say it was "your" list, rather something you got off rotoworld. Did not mean to ruffle any feathers. Also, SJax being ahead of MJD for durability reasons is laughable.
abrunn11 wrote: Dude, you did not say it was "your" list, rather something you got off rotoworld. Did not mean to ruffle any feathers. Also, SJax being ahead of MJD for durability reasons is laughable.
There was a thread on the same topic so I decided to make the same thread here. The actual list is mine though.
abrunn11 wrote: Dude, you did not say it was "your" list, rather something you got off rotoworld. Did not mean to ruffle any feathers. Also, SJax being ahead of MJD for durability reasons is laughable.
There was a thread on the same topic so I decided to make the same thread here. The actual list is mine though.
If I would have known it was your list I would not have posted that. I am not here to flame people.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by sadlyajetsfan » Thu Sep 16, 2010 4:37 pm 
