Eli or McNabb...WHIR as always!

[16FAC]

1pt for every 50 yds passing
6pts for every TD passing or rushing
-2 for INT

Need to chose between Eli and McNabb
Eli is going against big brother and I'm sure he will want to put up a show but the Colts Pass D is stellar and I'm not sure the absence of Sanders will pad Eli's stat line.

McNabb is going against the worst passing D in the league and Manning torched them last week for over 400 yds but does McNabb have the weaponry to put up anything like this.

Whoa is me please help.

Leave a link and I promise to hit yours!

[16FAC]

Know what makes me mad? People that put up WHIR but have no intentions of honoring it!

[Chappie]

I slightly prefer Eli. The matchups are about the same, and Eli has much better weapons at his disposal. Plus you never know what the sibling rivalry might produce.

[45 Starz]

Know what makes me mad? People that put up WHIR but have no intentions of honoring it!

lol , hmmmm did someone upset this guy? post your link, i'll help you buddy

[akkipash]

Know what makes me mad? People that put up WHIR but have no intentions of honoring it!

I actually do honor.

I would start Eli for the same reason, he has better weapons and receivers. I'm not going to trust McNabb until I see he's fitting in with WAS. He completed less than 50% of his passes last week. I was not impressed. I would start Eli.

Please help viewtopic.php?t=474449

[trixor85]

Roll with Eli.

[N.E. Challengers]

I have the same QBs in one of my leagues and am leaning towards Manning. While I dislike the number of INTs Eli threw last week, I feel like he will put up more yardage and TDs than McNabb. Did you see the DAL/WAS game? McNabb didn't look very comfortable. Some of it was the DAL D, but I think most of it was WAS.

Could you please take a look at mine...viewtopic.php?f=19&t=474354

[roostar1]

I prefer Eli over McNabb simply because he has more weapons at his disposal. I also think it will be a high scoring game between the Manning bros.

[ms1568]

Eli. McNabb just doesn't have the options that Eli does. Agreed that the Manning bros are just going rack up points all day in a shootout.

Mind taking a glance at mine? It's a toughy... http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?t=474506

[markulous]

I have the same QBs in one of my leagues and am leaning towards Manning. While I dislike the number of INTs Eli threw last week, I feel like he will put up more yardage and TDs than McNabb. Did you see the DAL/WAS game? McNabb didn't look very comfortable. Some of it was the DAL D, but I think most of it was WAS.

Could you please take a look at mine...viewtopic.php?f=19&t=474354

You really can't blame him for the INTs. All of them were tipped balls that his WRs should of caught. Especially for week 1, he looked pretty good out there and got decent protection from his O-line.

But I have the same QBs as well and I'm rolling with Eli. Indy defense looked terrible last week and this game could turn into a shoot out. Even if NYG decides to run the ball a lot, it's only going to set up the pass. They aren't going to be afraid to PA pass and throw with Eli.