Obviously a QB is going to give you way more points than any other position player, so I'd go with Cutler over any RB or WR here.
12 team H2H league, standard scoring, no PPR.
QB: Cutler, Kitna
RB: All Day AP, CJ2K, F.Jax, R.Brown, S. Greene, Dixon
WR: G. Jennings, Roy Williams, M. Williams (sea)
TE: J. Tamme
K: Hartley, Carpenter