Need a QB...3 Rosters, 2 Questions

[N.E. Challengers]

ESPN PPR league w/ 6 pts. TD

Roster (starters in bold...2 Flex RB/WR)
QB: Favre, Campbell
RB: Chris Johnson, Best, Donald Brown, Brandon Jackson
WR: Austin, Demaryius Thomas, Jacoby Jones, Knox, Camarillo
TE: Gates, Hernandez

In my league, Favre is avg. 5 points/wk and Campbell has been benched. Using Best or Gates, I am targetting teams w/ McNabb and Cutler. One team has Peyton, McNabb, Bradford, Ryan Matthews, Charles, Slaton, Jennings, Williams (TB), Boldin, Maclin, Robinson, Clayton, Roberts, Gresham and Miller. I offered Best for McNabb and Boldin. He shot it down. What would you request in exchange for Best?

Other roster has Brees, Cutler, Garrad, Moreno, Reggie Bush, Maroney, Kevin Smith, Collie, Fitz, Meachem, Murphy, Randle-El, Cribbs, Winslow and Mercedes Lewis. For Best, I requested Cutler and Collie. IMO, his roster is weak at RB so I think he should consider my trade. What would you request in exchange for Best?

I am having a hard time deciding what would be a fair trade for both parties. I really need some help. Please leave a link and I will offer my opinion on yours.

[JoshKnows46]

i think your giving up too much in both trades, and i wouldn't give up more than that.

first owner didn't accept your trade, so he wouldn't exept what i would offer. (ask the first owner if he know mattews has a high ankle spain, and could be out a few weeks, he's crazy not to take best...if tolbert is on the wire, i'd pick him up for trade bait with this owner.

the 2nd owner is crazy if he doesn't take that trade.

both owners have brees and peyton, so don't see why they wouldn't accept, best looked like a ppr mosnter last week.

trades look fair, if they don't accept, you just have to look somewhere else.

i'd also rather trade gates for a qb instead of best, since you also have hernadez.

try gates for maclin/mcnabb

[bluecheezit]

If the first owner denied your Best for McNabb/Boldin trade, then I don't think he's going to budge on anything, and you shouldn't give up more than that.

Second owner looks more plausible. Has he responded to your first offer yet? It's a good trade for him to take. If he doesn't do it, you could try Gates/(Thomas or Jones) for the same guys.

Thank you with mine as well.