Trade for Vick? WHIR

[Mugenlude]

Standard Scoring (no PPR) except QB's get 6 points for passing TD's.

My Team:
QB (1): Orton, Kolb
RB (2): A.Bradshaw, J.Charles, S.Greene, M.Barber, J.Snelling
WR (3): A.Johnson, B.Marshall, S.Smith (CAR), D.Mason
TE (1): Keller

I have the owner who picked up Vick off the waiver wire looking for a trade. He is looking to get B.Marshall in the trade.

His Team:
QB (1): Manning, Vick
RB (2): A.Foster, T.Hightower, J.Harrison, C.Taylor, P.Hillis
WR (3): Calvin.Johnson, W.Welker, Mike.Williams, J. Knox
TE (1): D.Clark

I was thinking of proposing Marshall/Snelling for Vick/M.Williams. Thoughts?

[Chalfdiggity]

i think if you can honestly get that trade that your stating you have to do it.. Snelling wont do what he did last week bc turner is completly healthy, while Vick would be ur starter. Marshall althou he is very talented just doesnt seem the same on the run first dolphins and henne as starter. Hopefully the M Williams ur stating is the one from the bucs not the seahawks bc it definatly makes a difference.. If its the Williams from the bucs try that deal and see what happens.

Please help me with mine..
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=476139

[prophecy135]

he wont' do that trade, Snelling wont play much as Turner will be back in action. I would try to package up a different deal, Marshall is too great a talent to get just Vick for, especially since who knows how long he'll be the starter.

[prophecy135]

you can offer that trade, but be prepared for it be countered or rejected. Snelling wont have a game like last week unless Turner goes down. You're asking for a #1 QB and a #1 WR for a #1 WR and a #2 back that plays behind one of the best backs in the nfl. you don't really need Vick with Orton on your roster, and marshall is an elite WR.

looking at both rosters, I dont really see a deal that makes both sides happy..

[sec338]

I wouldn't trade Mashall for Vick, trading an elite WR for a QB with questions is very dangerous.

Im in the similar situation (have garrard and hasselback to choose from for QB)

what do you think about trade Maclin for Vick?

[thepsychic]

Do that trade if it is accepted. I'd try to trade Steve Smith while his stock is still high in a package for Vick as your core WR1 & WR2 are very strong. I'm still not high on his full season value, especially with the QB position being pulled back and forth.

help: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=476039