Foster, Portis, or Tolbert? Pick 1...WHIR

[bisklimpkit]

I've got AP active versus Detroit, but now I need to choose from Foster vs Dallas, Portis @ St. Louis, or Tolbert @ Seattle. Who should I start from those 3 guys, and why?

Leave a link and I'll try to give you a hand on yours.

[everyrose]

How in the world do you have all these guys? You roll with Foster. Every week. Outside of sheer talent, Portis is eventually going to be handcuffed, and Tolbert's just no arian foster.

[bisklimpkit]

It's only a 10-team league and we have 6 bench spots. I got Peterson and Portis in the draft, and snagged Foster, Brandon Jackson, and Tolbert off of waivers/free agent pool. I've been fortunate, that's for sure.

Thanks for the advice. Anyone else have any thoughts?

[k.k.]

Foster all the way. If he bums out in coming weeks, sure then re-evaluate. But for now, that list, Foster.

[xway23]

Foster's a stud although I'd be concerned that HOU vs. DAL should be an air-fest. Fortunately, he can catch passes too, so you should have a safety buffer there. Tolbert is a worthy consideration only if Mathews sits, but I like both of these guys much better than Portis. I'd go with Foster since he can produce even without TD's.

viewtopic.php?t=476327

[ZeroPointZero]

Foster for sure.
Tolbert is getting the start, but I'd be shocked if he gets any more than about 12 carries. The guy has one play, up the gut, slam into some people, gain 4 yards. He will be out of gas after the first quarter, out for the 2nd, back in for the 3rd, out for the 4th, plus goal line carries if they have any.