Peyton or Donovan?

[russellthelovemuscle]

What would you do this week, start Peyton against the wicked old Denver D, or start Donovan against the Rams which is my gut instinct this week. I think Donovan will have a big game, but it's difficult to put Peyton on the bench! WHIR just want to hear some opinions, hopefully both ways.

[pundapun]

Go with Peyton. DMcNabb and WAS can go up big and then just run the ball till the end of the game.

Help http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=19&t=476499

[KobeaFootball]

Hello,

You NEVER sit Peyton. I don't care what matchup he has, its very rare that Peyton has a bad game against any defense.

Not that this matters any, but i've been a huge Eagles fan since i can remember. It dosent' matter what team Mcnabb is against. It's always a 50-50 with him.

Mcnabb is very inconsistent compared to other QBs of his calibur (aaron rogers, peyton manning, tom brady, etc etc)

Peyton is #1

[Navyseal]

Sure, McNabb COULD outperform Peyton this wkend @ the hapless Lambs, but it's not a sure thing, you just NEVER, EVER sit Peyton, period, not @ Denver, not ANYWHERE... and I AM starting McNabb over Eli, the OTHER Manning... lol

GL



*Big $$$ 12 tm, H2H Hyper-performance/Milestone keeper league:
QB-RB-RB-WR-WR-WR-TE-K-D/ST + several other options
*McNabb, Eli Manning
*AP,*T.Jones, J.Stew, M.Bush, Sproles
*Austin,*R.White,*Royal, Manningham, M.Thomas, Edelman
*Pettigrew, O.Daniels
*Kaeding
*NEP D/ST, NYG D/ST
(2-0, 4th in points)

[k.k.]

Despite matchups, I don't think you can ever justify sitting Peyton. IND will always throw the ball.

[electramax]

Not even a question, Manning 100%.

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

Do not sit manning except for his bye week...unless you like to lose of course

[Chuong9]

I would never sit P. Manning.

[Prosdo]

I would never sit P. Manning.

Ditto. Even if he doesn't light it up he is always consistent.