? Reggie Wayne and Matt Forte for Ray Rice and Mike Wallace?

[neonfish07]

My fellow fantasy-leaguers:

Should I make this trade? Please give detailed answers, and if you'd like post a link to your thread and I'll help you back.

I give:

Reggie Wayne
Matt Forte

I get:

Ray Rice
Mike Wallace

This was proposed to me, at first I dismissed it because Reggie Wayne is going to have an amazing year and Forte is showing potential to be a huge surprise. But on further thought, RB is definitely the weakness of my team and I think Ray Rice would bring some much needed consistency to the position and Mike Wallace should receive a boost when Roethlisberger comes back.

It comes down to this: which lineup is better?

WR1 Steve Smith (CAR)
WR2 Donald Driver
W3R Mike Wallace
RB1 Ray Rice
RB2 Beanie Wells/Fred Jackson/Cadillac Williams

-- OR --

WR1 Reggie Wayne
WR2 Steve Smith (CAR)
WR3 Donald Driver
RB1 Matt Forte
RB2 Beanie Wells/Fred Jackson/Cadillac Williams

12 team league. Standard Yahoo scoring.

What do you think?

Here's my current roster:

QB
Aaron Rodgers

WR
Reggie Wayne
Steve Smith (CAR)
Donald Driver
Jericho Cotchery
Devery Henderson

RB
Beanie Wells
Matt Forte
Fred Jackson
Carnell Williams
Donald Brown

TE
Dallas Clark

K
Rob Bironas

DEF
San Francisco

Thanks!!

[MadDog36]

Reggie Wayne
Matt Forte

side more complete roster with these two. Wallace is an unknown at this point.

[unkleskott]

Two pass-catching RBs, on decent offenses...I am sure Ray is bound to start living up to his potential eventually, but I Forte should have a pretty strong year. The upgrade isn't worth losing Wayne.

help?

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=476880