Andre for Collie/Benson

[nocode]

2 man keeper league. Looking to make this offer and see if it makes sense for you guys:

My team
QB: Orton, McNabb
RB: Wells, Donald Brown, Snelling, F Taylor (we lost Ryan Grant)
WR: Andre, Boldin, Maclin, Breaston, Knox
TE: Olsen, Daniels

his team
QB: Rodgers
WR: Austin, Collie, S Smith (CAR), TO, Mike Williams (SEA), Mike Sims-Walker
RB: Benson, Foster, McCoy, B Scott, Javon Ringer
TE: Shiancoe

He's looking to trade Benson/Collie for an elite WR. I'm obviously hurting with RB's since Grant went down and Wells was injured. Collie is keeper eligible at round 9 so that could be huge. His team is already pretty stacked and I just don't know how I would feel trading him Andre when he's also got Austin.

[nocode]

forgot to mention it's a PPR league.

[displaced longhorn]

i would go for

collie/foster
then collie/mccoy

[woowoo crew]

you need to counter and ask for collie and foster or collie and mccoy. i wouldn't take the collie/benson deal. if he rejects your offers, look elsewhere... such as to the mojo owner, especially since it's ppr.

help me please: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=477093