Trade McFadden for Moss?

[bc4l]

Hi all, am 1-2 right now and looking to upgrade the roster...need some opinions.

Standard yahoo scoring league, 1 QB, 3 WR, 2 RB, 1 TE, 1 W/R, K, D

my roster is:

QB: Drew Brees
WR: Steve Smith (car), Percy Harvin, Louis Murphy/Michael Crabtree
RB: Mendenhall, McFadden, Brandon Jackson, Addai
TE: Shiancoe

I have Cadillac Williams, Ryan Mathews, and Michael Vick on my bench (trying to trade Vick while his stock is high...but no one has bit so far)

The guy is offering me Randy Moss and Ricky Williams for McFadden...would you do it? I'm pretty average at WR and have some OK running backs. I'm just afraid Moss will under-perform this year while McFadden continues to be the stud everyone thought he would be.

Thanks in advance--torn on this one!

[bc4l]

shameless self bump

[muckhappy]

I would do it just to get Moss, plus your getting a decent option with williams. I have Mcfadden in one of my leagues too, but if I could get Randy Moss for Mcfadden definately. I hope this helps

[bc4l]

Thanks! I'm leaning toward accepting the trade...not 100% sure yet though.

Anybody else?

[bassackwards]

Yea...I think I would do this trade. Moss will make a huge upgrade to your WR's.