McNabb or Big Ben as QB2***100% WHIR***

[crashpad]

Ok I have Vick as my starting QB for now at least and am pretty happy with him. But my #2 is Alex Smith, not happy with him. I have two options for and upgrade.
1: Someone just dropped Big Ben so I can WW Smith for Roethlesberger

or

2: I have been offered a trade of McNabb and Nanee for LT. and Smith

I am pretty solid at RB so I can afford to loose LT but I actaully had him in as a flex this week. What do you guys think??? Leave a link I will Help back!!

QB: Vick, A. Smith,
RB: Rice, Charles, Forte, Hillis, LT2, T. Jones,
WR: R. Moss, R. Wayne, M. Clayton, M, Williams (TB)
TE: V. Davis, A. Hernandez
K: Nugent
DST: Bolts

[Chalfdiggity]

Easily go with dropping alex smith for big ben, no need to give up a valuable asset in LT when you can get a top 10qb in big ben for nothing.. Pick him up QUICK!! when big ben returns hell be great.

Please help with mine..
viewtopic.php?t=477549

[blueman]

I like Rothlisberger more than mcnabb, especially seeing that your not giving up anything extra to get him.

help with mine...viewtopic.php?t=477553

[wang259]

Either options can work for you - you're deep at RB and can afford to lose LT in a trade. Basically in the end, you have to decide whether you think Big Ben or McNabb is a better QB2. thanks for the help on mine

[Jear3]

Big Ben. He's probably a better option anyway, but in this case you won't be giving up players to get him.