P. Manning or M. Vick

[kasabb]

Manning has been excellent for me so far but I think Vick can rack up some points this w/end against Wash. Should I go with Vick?

[hngryDavy]

As sexy as going with Vick might seem at the moment I think you have to go with Manning. Even though Washington's D is pretty weak Manning is such a proven point scorer I think it would be a mistake to turn your back on him.

[prophecy135]

This breaks down more to how you feel about the rest of your team. If you feel confident that the rest of your team will put up good numbers and feel like taking a gamble at the QB position, I'd say go with Vick, he has the potential to throw for 300 and rush for 100. Peyton on the other hand is almost a given to get 300+ and 2-3 TD's, so if you want for sure points go with Peyton.