I'M STILL TORN-MCFADDEN/COLLIE FOR MATHEWS/JENNINGS? WHIR!

[Doctor P]

Ugh, I'm still torn, but would like to make a decision today because he may cancel the trade, and if this trade is going to be available, it's going to be this week, because if McFadden slows up against Houston, who currently ranks 2nd in the league in rush def, and maybe Collie doesn't have a ridiculous statline, and watch Jennings destroy the Lions and Mathews have a solid bounce back game coming off injury.

Can I get a few more opinions? WHIR

[CBMGreatOne]

Did you end up taking this trade? With as bad as Mathews has looked and with McFadden back, I think I'd take the DMac side today even with Collie out for another couple of weeks.

[Doctor P]

Nope....I decided to not take the trade so I still have McFadden.

[49ers2724]

keep Run Dmc

[Joeybagadonuts]

Id do this with Garcon back. Mathews is a good back who will emerge one of these weeks and Jennings is getting better. Mcfadden is at the height of his value...

HELP IN RETURN: viewtopic.php?t=483017

[Doctor P]

Some of you guys really have to read before blindly posting. This thread was from 3 weeks ago, and was only brought back into the light because someone asked if I accepted the trade. I said that I didn't. This trade is not available anymore. I'd rather keep McFadden. My WRs are just fine with Harvin, Lloyd, Mike Wallace, Bowe, and Collie(although I'm about ready to drop him). And Mathews is trash....