McNabb/McCoy/Knox for Henne/Moreno/Marshall

[Big Chief Triangle]

Thx for helping me out bro!

I would do it.

The main thing that I look for is "definite" stats during a player's bad weeks. Even during an off week you'll still get something.

[Hags888]

Thanks for the help on mine.

I view McNabb as being only marginally better than Henne, McCoy as being significantly better than Moreno, and Marshall as being light-years ahead of Knox. It seems like a fair trade to me, although definitely a HUGE trade. If it were me, I'd package McCoy and McNabb and try to get Henne/Marshall in return. Sometimes you always want to replace the positions you're trading, but you've got an abundance of RB, and he's (presumably) got an abundance of WR, so you both could stand to lose one and probably be ok.

[djadrock]

I would do it in a New York minute as long as you are comfortable going a little down at RB. I think QB is a push, WR you win (BIG TIME!) and RB he wins some. Who knows? Maybe Moreno comes back healthy and rolls.

[nogoat23]

I agree with the consensus. Go for it. Thanks for the help on mine.

[krock2010]

It is a close one, but I think I would do it.