MY MJD and Fitz for his Charles and Welker? WHIR

[STEVEO]

Looking to shake up my 1-3 team here, got an offer for my MJD and Fitzgerald for his Jamaal Charles and Welker.

PPR league with standard yardage and TD scoring.

Am I giving too much and abandoning MJD and Fitz too early? Or am I getting a huge upside guy in Charles and a PPR monster in Welker for 2 lame ducks (I mean this year, clearly I know MJD and Fitz are hugely talented and in bad situations)

Thanks, Steveo


QB: Schaub, Freeman
RB: MJD, D. Williams, Spiller, Portis, Stewart
WR: Fitzgerald, Smith (NYG), Driver, Maclin, Williams (TB), Murphy
TE: Gonzales
K: Gould
Def: GB

[taw856]

Eh, I'd stick with MJD and Fitz. Higher upside there based on pure talent IMHO. (And even if you did make this deal, I'd at least wait until after Welker's bye week -- there's nothing in it for you to make the trade Wk.5)

Mine: viewtopic.php?f=18&t=478644

[PensSteelersBucs]

Not even close. You're sending the two best player for the two worst players. Decline.

[phate83]

Since you're in a PPR league, Fitz for Welker may be a good way to go, Welker tends to get a lot of shorter catches.

[aznf007]

I agree with the other posts. I would stick with MJD especially in a ppr league. You could try to counter with DeAngelo instead of MJD but I doubt he'd accept. However it doesn't hurt to try I guess. If you can't get a deal done then none gained none lost.

My topic:

viewtopic.php?t=478791

[JackedSierra]

fairly even.. you are giving up the better rb, but you are getting the better wr.. fitz is junk this year, not because of him , but ari has no qb... you can be the best wr in the league but you cant do shit without a decent qb throwing you the ball...your taking a chance with charles, but he could post up same numbers as mjd.. fitz will not post same as welker.. id take the deal