Z. Miller & Greene for M. Bush, Hernendez & Smith, WHIR

[saemick]

I'm looking for some RB depth and the guy who has Greene is desperate for a win. Here's the offer:

I give: Mike Bush (or Fred Jackson), Aaron Hernandez, & Steve Smith (CAR)
I get: Zach Miller & Shonn Greene

here's my roster:
12-team, .5pt per reception
QB: Cutler, Vick
RB: Gore, Hillis, M. Bush, Fred Jackson
WR: Fitz, Jennings, S. Smith (CAR), Crabtree, M. WIlliams (TB), Dez Bryant
TE: Hernandez
K: Prater
D: NE
Scoring: 10yds rush/rec = 1pt, 25yds pass = 1pt, TD = 6pts, fumble/int. = -2pts

Should I do this? If so, should I offer Bush or Jackson?

please help as I need to make the offer tonight

thanks

[DemonDeacon]

this one is up in the air for me. Personally i like your team the way it is. That being said Miller has played great the last 2 games and looks like a solid number 1 te. Smith is the tricky one here b/c of his injury/qb problems. If you think Smith isn't going to be a viable starting option for the remainder of the year then i'd do the trade. But if you think Smith can return to number 2 wr numbers then i'd say no. Me personally I dont think i'd do it, but i have faith in Steve Smith which may be ill placed

help?
viewtopic.php?t=478830

[schmidty]

It's an interesting trade. The centerpiece's are a couple of massively disappointing buy-low guys. Though Greene is only an injury to a 30+ yo RB away from being a monster. That could happen. Smith? I just don't see what could happen to make his outlook get better, at least for this season. I think I like the Greene side, based on upside and it seems like this would be a bench RB spot (and Smith wasn't starting for you anyway). I don't see much difference between Bush and Jackson.

Getting Miller for Hernandez should be an upgrade (though both are playing well). Though there's a caveat - if this "Moss to the Vikings" thing goes through, Hernandez's value could skyrocket.