SLIM PICKINS" AT QB........WHO SHOULD I GO WITH?

[JoshKnows46]

Brett Farve @ Jets
Shaun Hill vs StL
Kevin Kolb @SF
Ryan Fitzpatrick vs Jac
Vince Young @Dal
Josh Freeman @Cin
Matt Cassel @Ind

[JoshKnows46]

[TheBlueCurtain23]

Favre + Moss + Monday Night Football = Huge

viewtopic.php?t=479143
viewtopic.php?t=479145

[prophecy135]

Brett Farve @ Jets
Shaun Hill vs StL
Kevin Kolb @SF
Ryan Fitzpatrick vs Jac
Vince Young @Dal
Josh Freeman @Cin
Matt Cassel @Ind

Out of those I'd probably have to go with Shaun Hill, he's got some decent weapons in Scheffler, Megatron and Best. Favre has the Jets D to contend with. Kolb has his inability to do anything to deal with, and the fact that the 49ers play better at home on both sides of the ball. Fitzpatrick doesnt really have any weapons to utilize. Freeman is a good option, but I dont like him more then Hill. Vince is also a good solid option, but I still think Hill is better. Cassel will be playing from behind and Indy's D loves to get after the QB when they dont have to worry about the run, which is the situation I see them in this week.

[JoshKnows46]

thanks guys

[OUTLAWZ650]

Favre could light it up, but I say go with Hill. You know they're going to pass. Minn has AP and I'm assuming they'll using him as always.

[NotJohnTillerman]

Tough call here.

As of now I think Favre would be my play. Creative play, maybe, but with that much talent and experience, his shiny new deep threat/required double cover, and both of their tendencies to perform under pressure, I think Favre has some strong upside here. Shaun Hill is probably the 'obvious' start, but that Rams D is getting consistently underrated (or outperforming their talent depending who you talk to) and.... he's Shaun Hill. There's a lot of downside in that.

Fitzpatrick is an interesting possibility as well. ESPN has him projected top 10 this week in my league's system, and a great matchup + a terrible team = possibly a lot of garbage time number padding.

[JackedSierra]

if you need an average amount of pts from a qb i would go with hill as the safe bet.. but if you need a homerun i think favre could have a huge game.. he may not be comfortable with moss yet but moss will be drawing double coverage off of percy.. either way a good nite for favre
help me.. viewtopic.php?f=18&t=479215

[JoshKnows46]

thanks guys, need more opinions, i'm leaning to farve cus i think st. louis d is better than people think and historiclly farve is amazing after bye weeks.....any more opinions?...talk me out of play against jets defense, if you think its a bad desision.