QB + Finley FOR RB + Shockey?

[taw856]

A guy in my league who is weak at TE is asking for TEs for RBs.

I hate giving up J. Finley, but I'm wondering if there's a deal here that makes sense...

MY TEAM
QB: B. Favre, (M. Vick), (J. Cutler)
RB: A. Foster, R. Rice, (C. Spiller)
WR: Ca. Johnson, H. Nicks, D. McCluster, (B. Marshall), (H. Ward) *=McCluster is a bye week fill-in.
TE: J. Finley
K: M. Nugent
DST: Ravens

HIS TEAM
QB: E. Manning
RB: S. Jackson, R. Mathews, (D. McFadden), (F. Jackson), (M. Barber)
WR: S.Smith-NYG, M. Sims-Walker, S. Holmes, (A. Johnson), (Jac. Jones)
TE: J. Shockey
K: S. Janikowski
DST: Cowboys

Would you trade Favre/Vick/Cutler + Finley FOR Jackson/Mathews/McFadden + Shockey?

[taw856]

bump to see if I can get more than zero views before being pushed off page 1

[taw856]

That's two times off the first pages of posts without a single view by anyone, can we make it three...?

[runningchoc]

I wouldn't do that. Moving one of your QB's for a RB would be a good idea, but downgrading at TE that far for one of the RB's you could get from him doesn't seem like a good idea at all. Mathews is the only one that has any appeal, but with Tolbert, I'm not so sure he's worth the dropoff from Finley to Shockey.