Matt Schaub or Carson Palmer

[SpankDDogg22]

Need help making this decision. I have Matt Schaub vs. Giants or Carson Palmer vs. Buccaneers. I always thought Schaub was a must start every week but Andre Johnson is hurt and Giants completely dominated the passing game on Monday Night. Would anyone still start Schaub or roll with Palmer this week? Thanks for the help!!!

[timtobey18]

Still gotta go with Schaub. Palmer just isn't that good anymore. Even with no name receivers, Schaub can get the job done.

[B3N1ZJAM1N]

I think you still have to go with schaub. I wouldn't want palmer starting for me with schaub playing

[jp05ser]

Schaub hands down....the giants pass D is BAD and Schaub having a good running game will keep the defense honest and Andre Johnson should be back this week as well... Palmer just isnt a good option anymore...just not the same....

please help with mine.... viewtopic.php?f=19&t=479332

[aldavis]

Schaub is a must start every week not a matchup QB like Palmer.