Would you do this trade? WHIR!

[bearsfanatic]

My team

QBs Kolb, Garrard, Gradkowski ( I know .. shopping )
RBs Addai, Pierre Thomas ,Torain, Hightower, Snelling
WRs AJ, Austin, Housh, Breaston, Burleson, Brandon Tate

The offer is his Brandon Jacobs, Tolbert, and Devery Henderson for my Thomas and Tate.
I had high hopes for Tate to step in where Moss was and fill out a nice WR corp, and I know Jacobs is in the doghouse and Matthews is at full strength again, but I'm thinking this might end up being better in the long run. Should I stay put and hope Tate excells with Brady and Pierre doesnt go off with no Bush for the next few weeks, or is this trade better for me long term. Thx for the reasoning and leave a link.

14 man league, so bare in mind the pickings are alot slimmer than most.

[garretterik]

No I would not do this trade. I am not huge on Tate, however Jacobs is a backup, Tolbert is a backup and Henderson has dropped off the face of the planet. At least there is upside with Tate and if Pierre is healthy he is the best player in the trade. Also, you will have to drop a player to make the trade.
Help me:
viewtopic.php?t=479401

[brady4president]

um no..... thomas is solid when healthy Tate may be a good player. he is offering garbage.

some help
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=479388