Trade - Nicks/Tolbert for Roddy/Beanie

[roysmalley]

What do you think? Who gets the better deal?

[garretterik]

I like the Roddy/Beanie side slightly better.
Nicks has been a break out player this year, but Roddy is Roddy.
The difference may be the fact that Tolbert is likely to lose touches and Beanie gain them if team RBs remain healthy.
Help me:
viewtopic.php?t=479407

[roysmalley]

Yeah, I'm leaning that direction as well. I think the RB's are a wash since tolbert will share and Wells is injury prone on a bad team. But is Roddy a big enough upgrade over Nicks?

[nygrenes]

I like roddy/beanie slightly better espaecially if it's ppr league. Roddy gets more targets than nicks and I think ends the year considerably (at least 5 spots) higher than nicks. RB's are a wash unless mathews gets injured again.

Mine:

viewtopic.php?t=479259

[brady4president]

roddy side a ton more. roddy is a pimp. nicks is nice but not roddy.

some help
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=479388