League Settings: 12 Team league; Start QB, 1 RB, 3WR, W/R Flex, TE D K; Scoring: 6pts/td 0.5 PPR WHIR!!!! leave a link
Offer: My Hillis, Forsett and B Tate for his B Jackson, L Murphy and M Thomas
My take, please agree or disagree: First off, Its an even deal. I will likely be dropping Forsett of Jackson tomorrow for a WW QB to start for Cutler. I don't like giving up the best player in the deal (IMO thats Hillis). Tate is a tough call because its speculation that he will perform well in replacement of Moss. I am optimistic, but looking for others opinions. I could sell high on potential or he could become a steal off the WW. If V Jackson gets traded to the pats, Tate is likely not worth much Murphy and Thomas would not crack my starting lineup if WR corps remains healthy If Andre Johnson doesn't play this week, I don't have a WR to fill in this week with Marshall and Tate on Bye.
My Team: Qb Cutler Rb Turner, Hillis, Torain, Lynch, Barber, Forsett WR A Johnson, Marshall, Nicks, S Moss, B Tate TE Gates
His Team Qb Rodgers Rb Addai, Betts, B Jackson, Darby Wr Boldin, L Moore, M Wallace, L Murphy, M Thomas, H Douglas TE Finley
Is the only reason you are doing this is to get a WR bye week fill in? If so, what WRs are on your wire? Because I don't like that trade for you at all. I would rather take a flier on somoene for 1 week than do that deal. I don't see how it helps you other than this week.
12 Team League. We start 2 QBs and get .5 PPR, otherwise standard scoring QBs: Stafford, Fitzpatrick, Collins RBs: Charles, Mendenhall, Best, Starks, Carter, Karim WRs: D. Jackson, Marshall, S. Smith, Green, TE: Hernandez, Cook
I agree with Hoosier. If you are giving up Hillis you should get much better value than that. Either advertise to your league that you are willing to apart with P Hill or use the WW for a one week fill.
I'm fine with selling high on Tate. Your you could get Murphy for Tate based on upside I would do this deal, I still don't think it is worth Hillis however. If you have the depth at runningback to give up Hillis I think you can aim higher. Look at the Jennings, Nicks, D Jack, Welker, etc. owners. They may need backs and may take Hillis straight up.
thanks for the help on mine. Jackson is almost bustworthy, the packers don't have much faith in him, he's just no tthat talented. The potential upside with Tate is too tasty to trade away just yet. The V Jax deal has been shot down by most experts so I'm not to worried about that and by no means should you be parting ways with Hillis, he's playing out of his mind right now and is worth more than what is being offed. I say hold onto what you got.
Send questions direct to my twitter account @gallegosdavidm