M.Vick for Sanchez and welker?!? This a fair deal?WHIR

[SD2k10]

Been offered sanchez and welker for my Vick....is this a good deal for me? I'm in a 12 team IDP league....am I crazy to consider this?

[aldavis]

According to your sig you aleady took it. I would take it too. Then move Orton, target the owner of Cutler or wait for another QB to go down.

Help in return?
http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/posting.php?mode=post&f=18

[SD2k10]

Thanks for a reply. I have multiple leagues. That's jut one haha. So you feel Vick isn't worth keeping?

[aldavis]

Depends who your starting QB is. Vick is an every week player when healthy. Sanchez is a matchup QB that doesn't take risks, which means he has a better chance of staying healthy. Welker is a big add with Moss gone. As long as you have another QB to start every week or alternate matchups with Sanchez I would take it.

What do you think about the Ravens D?
Click --> http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/posting.php?mode=post&f=18

[Controlled Chaos]

If the roster in your sig isn't relative to this question, it's hard to answer. Need to know your starting QB, but if it's anyone decent and it should be because Vick was a waiver pick up, then you make this move just to get Welker.

[SD2k10]

Yea it's Rodgers..I took Rodgers round one in all my leagues....but with moss gone won't he see more double teams? I feel welker was valuable cuz moss was always double covered....Now as their primary receiver( till they pick someone up) he may not see as much looks. Plus with Hernandez , Tate and , gronkowski now factors...idk man

[Controlled Chaos]

Depends on who you ask, but I feel "welker was valuable cuz moss was always double covered...." is absolute horseshit. I keep hearing it, but I won't believe it until I see it. Welker gets open underneath...he will still get open underneath no matter who is running on the other side. Plus you have nothing to lose....Vick should NEVER start over Rodgers.

[SD2k10]

Shit I forgot to mention the team format

Qb
Qb
Wr
WR
WR
RB
RB
TE
Flex
Flex
Sorry guys...I need to start two qb's my mistake guys

[Thor]

I would do it.

You're trading someone that is just sitting on your roster and probably never starting for a legitimate starter. Bench points don't count, starting points do. Anytime I can make my starting line up better I do the deal. You can't control injuries, it's nice to have depth but depth doesn't get you points.


viewtopic.php?t=479543

[Controlled Chaos]

I still do it.