Right now I have McCluster going. Granted, we don't get points for return yards, but he's a playmaker and he could rip one off for a TD. Plus, the Chiefs may pull some tricks out of their sleeve to beat the Colts. I just have a feeling on this one.
If Murphy or Crabtree had better matchups (my other two WR on the bench), I'd probably roll with them, but I feel like rolling the dice on this one.