P. Manning for Orton or McNabb? WHIR

[Remy]

I have been offered Orton, Mike Wallace, Marshall or Boldin for Peyton Manning and Mike Williams . I am hurting at Wide Reciever. I am worried about Orton and having him as my QB. Orton started hot last season then fizzled the second half. Should I make this trade and if so should I take Boldin or Marshall.

Also another trade would be Manning and Mike Williams for Roddy White, Santana Moss and McNabb. Is this trade seem better then the Orton Trade?

Current format is Standard. 1 point for every 10 yards receiving or rushing. 6 points for TD. This is not a PPR League.

My Current Lineup

Peyton Manning
Pierre Garcon
Eddie Royal
Mario Manningham
Michael Turner
MJD
Shiancoe
Bironas
Dallas D/ST

Bench
Jamaal Charles
Mike Williams (TB)
Brandon Tate
Steve Johnson
Chris Cooley

[TheGhost]

That is a tough choice but I think I'd stay put. I think this trade might be a toss up and to give a guy like Peyton away usually isn't a smart idea. On the other hand Orton has been putting up great numbers even when they lose. The Broncos running game stinks, so I think they continue to throw. But, I'd take Boldin over Marshall if you take the deal. Better QB and better team. Good luck!

[drew1265]

If you were to make a trade i would do the white moss mcnabb deal. White may be the #1 wr this season moss looks top 20 and while orton is better than mcnabb, mcnabb is servicable i would just make sure to land a decent backup to platoon with him see if you can buy low on flacco

[16FAC]

Ummm....NO and then again....Hell no. How many times have you watched Orton Light in up a few games and then fall off a cliff? i have witnessed it so many times. How many times have you seen Payton do it? I know Payton had a tough game last week but No one gives credit to KC's D. They are much improved and planned for the situation. I would stick with Payton and look to the waiver for some WR's

Thanks for mine!!

[techman5003]

I would say No as well. The white, moss, mcnabb is intriguing but I just can't bring myself to part with a horse like Peyton.

thanks for the help with mine

[Habslive]

Peyton Manning is the best player in the NFL. You do not trade him because he is capable of 4 or 5 TD passes against any defense. Go to the waiver wire for help at WR. All of your RB's are underperforming. See if you can get someone to buy low on them with one of their upper to mid level receivers.

[gergy9]

DO NOT TRADE MANNING! Unless they are giving up alot more than anything i have seen here. Manning can win for you single handed.

viewtopic.php?t=480199

[zoolander12]

I wont trade Manning unless you get back Miles Austin, Andre Johnson, Calvin types + serviceable QB.

[SumG]

I think I'd hold on to Manning. It's tempting, but not enough.

[LJcomeback09]

peyton manning is a horse....end of story. stay put.

help with mine?http://www.fantasyfootballcafe.com/forums/viewtopic.php?f=18&t=480218