MJD for McCoy?? Trade help

[sfehnel]

Hey guys I need some trade help! I have just been offered Maurice Jones-Drew for Lesean Mccoy? Should I do this trade? Obviously a couple weeks ago this would be a no brainer, but with mccoy playing lights out and mjd not finding the end zone i'm a little hesitant, would i be crazy to not accept this deal? Thanks for your help!!

Qb Flacco
RB Jaamal Charles
RB Lesean Mccoy
WR Anquan Boldin
WR Donald Driver
OP Joesph Addai
OP BenJarvus Green Ellis
TE Brent Celek
Bench Bryalon Edwards
Bench Tim Hightower
Bench Lee Evans
Bench Josh Cribbs

[Ozymandias19]

No, and a couple weeks ago, this would still have been a no. :p

[beavis69]

Don't do it. McCoy is looking good even with a cracked rib!!! PHI offense is looking good and that will help McCoy alot.

viewtopic.php?f=18&t=480293

[seahawks506]

MJD has a tough schedule going forward, so the owner is probably trying to sell high. I wouldn't do it, but see if he can throw something extra in and emphasize the fact that (you know) his schedule will get tougher.

[sfehnel]

wow thanks guys.. definately some surprising answers here....i guess I am just focusing on the household fantasy name of MJD too much

[PensSteelersBucs]

I would absolutely do this. MJD is a far superior fantasy RB then McCoy. Very surprised at these responses.

[Ozymandias19]

After five games, every stat you can think of says the opposite. Ealges have better WR's, two more efficient QB's, a better offensive coach. MJD is starting to share reps more. Mccoy is not. I see no reason other than what he has done in the 'past' to rate him above Mccoy.

You have to look at the stats and the team around the player, not the name.

[sfehnel]

Ahh this is so tough.. MJD is probally as low as he'll be all year and Mccoy is probally at his highest value

[sec338]

i was thinking of trading for MJD too, sending some type of package of Jamal Charles and something for him, what do you think?