trade review, please help. whir.

[jwchops]

I've just been offered Brandon Marshall and Matt Forte for Steven Jackson and Malcom Floyd.

lineup without trade:
Ray Rice, Sjax, Hillis, Brown
Roddy White, Malcom Floyd

lineup with trade:
Ray Rice, Forte, Hillis, Brown
Roddy White, Brandon Marshall

which do you like better?

[Hoosierdad]

Close one.

I like Jackson over Forte. I know Forte has had some huge games. But Jax will give you more consistent scoring each week. If Jax could get in the end zone, he'd be top 5.

I like Marshall a little more than Floyd, but not by as much as I would think. Bottom line is, Rivers is going to air it out. So while Marhsall may be the bettrer WR, Floyd is going to have better chances to score those big weeks. I would decline.

help?
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=480345