E.Manning/T.Gehart FOR V.Young/D.Bryant (WHIR)

[VIKINGFAN]

I am in a 12 team deep roster league, we start 2 QB's 2 RB's 4 WR's 2 TE's 2K's and IDP players......I am floundering this season to a 2-3 record, it could be allot worse......

Just got offered the following: (round means the keeper slot he would be next years draft) Remember its a 2 start QB league....I am building for next year, Young would be a nice cheap keeper @ 16th rd.

HE GETS:
QB - E.Manning (non keeper eligible)
RB - T.Gehart (14th rd keeper next year)

I GET:
QB - V.Young (16th rd keeper next year)
WR - D.Bryant (5th rd keeper next year)

Thoughts???? selling low on Manning, should I expect a better return?

[sadlyajetsfan]

I don't do any keeper leagues but to me even with Gehart being a great talent I don't think he's worth much, even as a keeper. Bryant seems to be the best keeper out of that bunch. I'd rather take the hit at QB and get Bryant.

[LJ's Crush]

I don't know what your lineup is but dez for eli is good unsure how great dez will be

[RealWisconsinCheese]

I don't play in keeper leagues, so I'm a little out of my element here. If this trade means that you get Eli back next year, I'd maybe do it. But otherwise, it does seem like you might be going a little too low on Eli's value. I understand that Dez could be a great prospect in a keeper, but I'm just a little too uncertain about his future performance. Not sure if that helped, but thanks for the input on my trade post

[Remy]

I would keep Manning and Gehart. V.Young is not good imo and Dez Bryant has Austin and Williams to fight touches for and they are not going anywhere for a long time.

My Topic
viewtopic.php?t=480482

[JoshKnows46]

I would keep Manning and Gehart. V.Young is not good imo and Dez Bryant has Austin and Williams to fight touches for and they are not going anywhere for a long time.

My Topic
viewtopic.php?t=480482

i don't anything that much about keepers, but i agree with this^^

[VIKINGFAN]

Thanks guys,

But Its a 2 start QB league, and I can't keep Manning past this season, (NON KEEPER) but getting Vince Young I can keep him with my 16th rd pick-slot, next year. Getting Bryant is a bonus if he turns it on the rest of the way, he might have value @ the 5th slot keeper.

So people think I can get more for Eli Manning? I am having my doubts. he has been awful this season, until the Texans game.

[blueman]

Thanks for the help with mine. If your just looking at next year then i would go ahead and do that trade. Young would be a decent #2 qb and bryant is a lot better keeper than toby.

[Champs85]

Id take Bryant and the upside over eli manning, young isn't a bad qb either he can run and the rushing points add up ...
help me out here viewtopic.php?t=480587

[DemonDeacon]

i think i'd make this trade. im curious to know who else you have at qb tho. I have high hopes for Dez who has the talent to be elite in this league. how many yrs can you keep a player?