Z Miller for Charles (WHIR)?

[Acadia]

To a Finley guy, is this a fair trade? I send him Oakland's Miller for his Jamaal Charles? Who gets the better?
I would pick up Carlson, Daniels, or more likely Heath Miller.

QB: Shaub
WR: Wayne
WR: Marshall
RB: Steven Jackson
RB: J Addai
TE: Z Miller
WR/RB/TE: Peyton Hillis

Bench:
Steve Smith (NYG)
Brandon Jackson
Marshawn Lynch
M Tolbert
Donald Brown
Mike Hart
Hines Ward

PPR, 10 team league
Passing Yards 20 yards per point; 5 points at 300 yards
Rushing Yards 10 yards per point; 5 points at 100 yards
Reception Yards 10 yards per point; 5 points at 100 yards
6 point per TD, 1 pt per Reception

[passthekiesch]

I don't think you lose too much going from Zach to Heath Miller with Big Ben coming back, and with Charles you add some much needed depth to your RBs. You definitely win out on this deal if the guy is willing to do it. I don't see why he wouldn't just keep Charles and pick up Heath Miller though, unless he's that strong at RB.

[billycent]

Obviously u win in this deal, but I agree w/the last guy, I don't see why he just wouldn't pick 1 of those guys up himself and hold on to J.C. Thnx for the help on mine.

[Tony Micelli]

It depends on how desperate he is for a TE now that he doesn't have Finley.

What Free agent TE's are available? I think its a great opportunity to get Charles cheap ... I think he has some big games in store..

Help me out man?
viewtopic.php?t=480545

[JoshKnows46]

i'd defintly do it, but i doubt the other guy will want to give up charles.

[randomfan523]

I am very pro-charles so i would trade miller to get him. Then i would pick up aaron hernandez if he is still availible or owen daniels.

thanks for help on mine!

[Mitch Cumstein]

Great deal for you. A starting running back for a tight end is a no brainer. Plus there are so many similar tight ends this year that you could pick a new one up nearly every week based on the match up.

[bassackwards]

If he takes it this is a GREAT deal for you...get it done!