Better going forward- Crabtree or Gaffney? WHIR

[passthekiesch]

I'm planning on packaging one of these guys with Jay Cutler to trade for Kyle Orton. I need some consistent QB play, and with the way Denver throws the ball, I have faith in Kyle Orton, at least as I wait to see if Schaub gets his act in gear.

My question to you is which one is more worth holding onto? It's a 0.5 PPR league with otherwise standard scoring. Gaffney is tied for 6th in the league in catches, but there are other weapons in Denver. Crabtree, on the other hand, got off to a pretty slow start, but the new Off. Coord. in San Fran seems intent on making him a focal point in the Niners offense.

Opinions on who has more upside going forward? As always, leave a link and I'll help you out...

[woods_opc]

From an upside perspective, Crabtree no question. This guy has insane talent and if he remains a 7-10 catch per game guy he is a must start every week.


help?
viewtopic.php?t=480572

[LJ's Crush]

Crabtree on the upside

help viewtopic.php?t=480595

[mattpullman]

Not to mention Crab's the #1 WR, whereas Gaffney's the #3. I see Crabtree letting owners down this week, due to the work of Nnamdi, but he's a solid play as far as the rest of the season goes.