Huge deal need advice. WHIR.

[sec338]

Thinking of trading: (PPR League)

Calvin Johnson
Jamal Charles
Dez Bryant
Zach Miller

for

Frank Gore
Vernon Davis
Hines Ward

am I giving up to much? What about if I substituted Bouldin for Hines Ward?

Thanks for the help, leave you link and ill help you out.

[tmacuf]

im not sure which your giving. if getting boldin then def, hes better than ward. id do it for boldin but not ward, megatron is too much better than ward
HELP ME
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=480622

[prophecy135]

Calvin Johnson
Jamal Charles
Dez Bryant
Zach Miller

for

Frank Gore
Vernon Davis
Hines Ward

Well Megatron when healthy is >> Ward. Gore >> Charles. Vernon > Miller. and I'm guessing Dez is just a throw in at this point. I mean, I guess its how your team is set up, if you need a RB and CAN give up Megatron, I guess I'd do it. Miller and Davis are almost a coin flip at this point, so it's basically megatron for gore, and charles for ward? I think you have to offer it with Boldin in there, if he takes it great, but more then likely he wont. If you're okay with ward you can re offer it, but i'm still not sure the other owner would do this unless he's overly stacked at RB.

[dolphan34]

Don't do it. Jamaal Charles could become the top fantasy back if Todd Haley finally gives him the start he deserves. You will have a big hole in WR from losing Calvin Johnson with nothing to replace it with. Bryant has some potential, especially if your league gives points for returns.

If he put in Boldin instead of Ward, I would consider it, but I still think he would be getting the better deal.


please help viewtopic.php?t=480608