Should this trade go through? You be the judge! PLEASE!

[AJPennSt]

5-0 team (commish) receives: Roddy White and Aaron Rodgers
0-5 team (vice-commish) receives: Matt Schaub, Jahvid Best, and Vincent Jackson

This trade seems unbelievably suspect to me. Should I be creating a stink about this like I am?

[steelcurtain]

No, I think it's you're more worried about another team getting better.

Matt Shaub currently > Rodgers
Roddy White > Best
But if VJax plays at the end of Oct like he did in 2009 then it's a wash.

[Chalfdiggity]

umm honestly its a little suspect..

Rodgers > Schaub
White > Best

if jackson plays then the deal has evened up but since he isnt returning till week 12 and should play around then it just seems like its a bit suspect.. i understand that it looks kinda even but best is alil hurt and never know with him, and schaub just hasnt looked the same this year..

Rodgers is top 3qb and white is a top 5wr.. seems like the kid who is 0-5 is giving up while staying somewhat competive..

Please help with mine..
viewtopic.php?f=18&t=480742