I'm done with Schaub. I can't handle the point swings. I'm not dropping him just yet, but for the next two weeks, who do I go with? I have narrowed it down to V. Young and C. McCoy, and maaaaybe D. Garrard.
So, who do I pickup and play? Or do I run with Schaub AGAIN despite KC's great performance against IND?
Things I'm thinking about: V. Young has JAC which is a plus, but he never throws for more then 200 yards. C. McCoy. It's his debut, and it's against PIT, but it could easily turn into a QB shootout and Hillis is sore. D. Garrard plays TEN again a plus, but just like young, doesn't do much on total yards.
I actually like Garrard of those 3 (though I have Schaub and will be starting him... agree, he's been disappointing, but he's been disappointing for a top-tier QB). He never gets those 350 yd games, but he's solid and consistent. McCoy is too fresh, you need to see what he's got. Young is to inconsistent I think.
Port of the allure of McCoy is that he's new. I have a feeling he could rise to the challenge. Sure he'll throw two picks, but he could also go for 180-200 yrds and two tds.
Of the three I like Young. I have both Young and Schaub on my team and I'm rolling the dice with Young. I think Schaub is either going to be bust (single digit points AGAIN!!) or he'll go off on KC for 300+ and at least 2 TD's. With Young though I think you get JAC stacking the box against Johnson which will open a lot of single coverage and oppportunities for Young to scramble. I think he gets at least one pass TD and one Rush TD ( and in my league Rush TD=6 and Pass TD=4) and I'm pretty sure Schaub won't rush for a TD.
As for Garrard, I had him early in the season and dropped him cuz I couldn't stomach his wekk 2/3 outings.
I would go with VY. JAC is one of the bottom 5 against the past, and that is before trying to stop CJ2K. McCoy will get destryed. Garrard is just not good.
CptBackfire wrote:I'm done with Schaub. I can't handle the point swings. I'm not dropping him just yet, but for the next two weeks, who do I go with? I have narrowed it down to V. Young and C. McCoy, and maaaaybe D. Garrard.
So, who do I pickup and play? Or do I run with Schaub AGAIN despite KC's great performance against IND?
Things I'm thinking about: V. Young has JAC which is a plus, but he never throws for more then 200 yards. C. McCoy. It's his debut, and it's against PIT, but it could easily turn into a QB shootout and Hillis is sore. D. Garrard plays TEN again a plus, but just like young, doesn't do much on total yards.
saberstud75 wrote:I would go with VY. JAC is one of the bottom 5 against the past, and that is before trying to stop CJ2K. McCoy will get destryed. Garrard is just not good.
"BUT GARRARD IS A TOP TEN FANTASY QB EVERY YEAR!"
Lol. Sorry, a friend in my league said that last year while picking him up like 6th or 7th round. Had to quote it. He lost.
LOL, I wish I had a few guys like your friend in my league. Garrard actually got called out by a previous teammate for talking about himself like he is an elite QB.
Good luck with VY, I know the guys at yahoo and FFB toolbox are high on him.
CptBackfire wrote:
saberstud75 wrote:I would go with VY. JAC is one of the bottom 5 against the past, and that is before trying to stop CJ2K. McCoy will get destryed. Garrard is just not good.
"BUT GARRARD IS A TOP TEN FANTASY QB EVERY YEAR!"
Lol. Sorry, a friend in my league said that last year while picking him up like 6th or 7th round. Had to quote it. He lost.
Cafe Home
Fantasy Baseball
Fantasy Basketball
Fantasy Hockey
by CptBackfire » Thu Oct 14, 2010 7:59 pm 
