Umm, you do realize that Orton is seond in the league in yards passing this year, only 1 TD behind from being tied for 3rd most, and only 3 passes behind Peyton for most attempts in the league. He's on a pass happy team so of course he's MUCH more valuable than Ryan. However, that also means that you SHOULD be able to get a lot more for him in trades if that's where you are heading with this. Then it all comes down to what you can get and which combination gives you the best starting lineup. Me, if I'm dropping one then I'd drop Ryan.
This aint a NYC auto garage, if it aint broke, dont fix it.
12 team redraft: Rivers (Q1), CJ (R1), McFadden (R2), B Wells (R3), Caddy (R4), Forsett (R5), AJ (W1), Fitz (W2), Royal (W3), Sims-Walker (W4), V Jax (W5), V Davis (T1), Kaeding (K1), Jets (D1)