Shaub, Harvin, Rice for Brees, Jennings, Mendenhall??? WHIR

[skoo9382]

i've been offered M.Shaub, P.Harvin, and R.Rice for D.Brees, G.Jennings, and R.Mendenhall.

In my opinion

Shaub < Brees
Harvin >/= Jennings
Rice >/= Mendenhall

Would you guys do it???? Will help in return. Leave a link.

[Cardphan]

Whats your record? If its good I wouldn't mess with your team. Mendy's bye is out of the way, but if its PPR take Rice. I think Jennings will get more attention in the future. Keep your team.

viewtopic.php?t=480821

[dcmayer1979]

Thanks for your help on mine. Funny, your Forte suggestion is fitting because the guy owns Forte too. ANYWAY, I pass on the deal below. It's tempting with Rice coming off a big week, but Mendy has been jsut as good if not better. Just because Rice is a top 5 fantasy pick doesn't mean Mendy might not be up there next year. Also, I am a Percy owner and have been shopping him like crazy this week. His trade value is HIGH right now, but I don't have THAT much faith in him. I think it's a wash with Jennings and no matter how Brees is playing...Brees to Shaub (who also has been so-so) is a big downgrade.

My vote: Pass on this one

i've been offered M.Shaub, P.Harvin, and R.Rice for D.Brees, G.Jennings, and R.Mendenhall.

In my opinion

Shaub < Brees
Harvin >/= Jennings
Rice >/= Mendenhall

Would you guys do it???? Will help in return. Leave a link.

[skoo9382]

Some more info.

I'm currently 1st in my league at 4-1 and it's a PPR league.

Thanks for the help guys~

[jblood5150]

I like your team better before the trade.

[dcmayer1979]

I'm back. 4-1 with an underperforming Brees and Jennings?! Stay put. This is definitely an 'if it ain't broke' situation.

[woods_opc]

i agree with the above. Stay put. Jennings is going to be getting the ball more going forward as well. With FInley out those targets should go his way. He also met with the coaching staff this week about getting involved more in the offense.

Keep your current guys!


help?
viewtopic.php?t=480831